Christmas Would You Rather Questions


Christmas Would You Rather Questions

Download a fun digital version of the activity as well as a printable student version.

Here are some fun “Would you rather…” Christmas questions to use during the holiday season.

“Would You Rather”, “This or That” – Whatever you call this game, your students will love it! 

You’ll love the:

  • Respectful Discussion & Debate
  • Critical thinking skills
  • Communicating thoughts and ideas
  • Defending thoughts and opinions
  • Being open to new perspectives
  • Flexibility in thinking
  • Adopting a personal point of view

Christmas Would You Rather Questions

WOULD YOU RATHER have to loudly sing the chorus of “Jingle Bells” every time you walk into a room for a week
OR… have to wear a Santa suit to school every day for a week

WOULD YOU RATHER make presents for your family instead of buying them
OR… make ornaments for your Christmas tree instead of buying them

WOULD YOU RATHER not celebrate Christmas this year
OR… not celebrate your birthday this year

WOULD YOU RATHER have Frosty the Snowman for a friend
OR… Rudolf the Red-Nosed Reindeer for a friend

WOULD YOU RATHER have mistletoe hanging in your bedroom doorway
OR… have a large, decorated Christmas tree in your bedroom doorway

WOULD YOU RATHER have Christmas tree tinsel for hair
OR… have fingernails that light up like Christmas lights

WOULD YOU RATHER be at home on Christmas and get lots of presents
OR… go to Disneyland for Christmas but not get any presents

WOULD YOU RATHER eat your cereal with eggnog instead of milk
OR… eat a candy cane sandwich

WOULD YOU RATHER live in a giant gingerbread house
OR… ride on the Polar Express

WOULD YOU RATHER be allowed to only eat fruitcake for two days
OR… be allowed to only eat candy canes for two days


Christmas Would You Rather Questions

WOULD YOU RATHER write a five-paragraph essay about the meaning of Christmas
OR… solve a page of Christmas-themed math problems

WOULD YOU RATHER have a nose that glows red like Rudolf’s
OR… have pointy ears like an elf

WOULD YOU RATHER visit the North Pole
OR… visit Bethlehem

WOULD YOU RATHER receive socks for Christmas
OR… receive a dictionary for Christmas

WOULD YOU RATHER be given $100 for Christmas to buy things for yourself
OR… be given $1000 before Christmas to use to buy gifts for other people

WOULD YOU RATHER get many small presents for Christmas
OR… get one big present for Christmas

WOULD YOU RATHER have a job wrapping presents at the mall
OR… have a job taking pictures of children sitting on Santa’s lap at the mall

WOULD YOU RATHER be one of Santa’s elves
OR… be one of Santa’s reindeer

WOULD YOU RATHER see The Nutcracker
OR…dance in The Nutcracker

WOULD YOU RATHER spend a day watching Christmas videos
OR…spend a day Christmas shopping at the mall



Christmas Readers Theater Who Stole Santa's List

You Might Also Like This:

This Christmas Readers’ Theater will be the highlight of the season! It’s low prep, great for distance learning, and kids love it!

Check out “Who Stole Santa’s List?

Looking for more Christmas resoures? We have a 20 Christmas Writing Prompts blog post and a Best Read Alouds blog post that you can check out!


Would You Rather Questions

20 Questions to Ask Students
Teaching Theme Ideas
Morning Meeting Questions & Daily Classroom Slides
Conversation Starters: 100+ Prompts to Get Your Students Thinking
  • Join Minds in Bloom UNLIMITED!
  • FREE PLANNER!

    FREE PLANNER!
  • Reading Practice for the Whole Year

    Close Reading Comprehension Practice
  • Make Learning Fun!

    Using Task Cards in the Classroom
  • You might also like these posts!

    Spring Writing Prompts for students

    20 Spring Writing Prompts

    20 Spring Writing Prompts What are some things you can do in the springtime that you cannot do during winter? Make a list of every

    Cookie Consent Banner by Real Cookie Banner